An action plan for a plant based future.

An action
plan for
a plant
based
future.

 

An open letter to the AI industry and Effective Altruism community on how to fund animal welfare, climate change and public health all at the same time.

“Newly-minted AI millionaires have already donated tens of millions this year to help factory-farmed animals. Many plan to give much more. We don’t yet know how much, but this could be a step-change for our movement.” – Lewis Bollard, “The AI Windfall”, Farm Animal Welfare newsletter, August 5, 2026.

Signatories so far:

Expert Signatories

Group Signatories

Individual Signatories

View our Expert Signatories

Loading



View our Group Signatories

Loading



Our Report

Our OPEN LETTER

Open Letter for Beyond Cage-Free

We are calling on Effective Altruists to pivot their focus area and the AI Windfall funding away from welfarist reforms toward plant-based initiatives that create multiplier benefits for animals, climate, health, food security, and reduced pandemic risk.

Our unsustainable global food system has become one of the greatest threats we face. The AI windfall presents an unprecedented opportunity to reshape the future of animal philanthropy. This comes at a time when the broken food system is accelerating climate change, biodiversity collapse, and public health threats, and leading to exploitation of a growing number of farmed animals, marine life, and invertebrates. What should success in animal philanthropy actually be measured by? This letter argues that the central metric of animal philanthropy should shift from cage-free campaigns and tech welfare to plant-based campaigns which reduce the total number of animals in the food system. Cage-free campaigns, for example, worsen greenhouse gas emissions, acidification, eutrophication, and land use, and increase the number of hens in the food systems to produce the same number of eggs. Plant-based food system transformation should become the main priority for animal philanthropy because it reduces the number of animals bred into the food system and creates multiplier benefits across animal protection, climate mitigation, reduced water and land use, public health, and food security.

Challenge

The climate crisis has fundamentally changed the strategic landscape for animal philanthropy. Our food systems lead to the exploitation and suffering of over 90 billion land farmed animals and trillions of aquatic animals for food and contribute a third of the greenhouse gases, mainly from meat, dairy and eggs. The numbers continue to grow each year, whereas a Harvard study on options for a Paris-Compliant food system found consumption of meat needs to peak by 2030 to avoid catastrophic climate change. The challenge we face is that animal welfare approaches sidestep the key metric of the number of farmed animals in the food system and treat climate and public health as negative externalities. Animal, climate, and public health crises are often compartmentalized, and progress in one area can sometimes inadvertently undermine another.

Animals

Cage-free campaigns illustrate this challenge. Many philanthropic organizations have supported corporate welfare reforms, particularly cage-free campaigns. PETA’s White Paper on the Failure of Cage-Free Housing Systems to Reduce Overall Hen Suffering states the welfare of hens in cage-free egg systems is “either marginally improved, unchanged, or, in some respects even worsened.”

While cage-free systems improve welfare outcomes with respect to ability to spread wings and preen, turn around, forage, and build nests compared with battery cages, they share similar welfare challenges in factory farms with respect to illnesses such as ovarian cancers, egg blockages, and prolapses, male chick killing, beak searing, induced moulting, and disruption to biological rhythms due to lighting. However, cage-free hens face worse welfare conditions than battery cage hens due to higher bacterial and fungal infections, social hierarchy stress and conflict, poor air quality leading to pulmonary, tracheal, skin, and eye injury, injurious pecking, feather loss, and cloacal cannibalism, keel bone injury due to falling and aggression, and mass killing due to infectious disease.

Climate & Planetary Boundaries

The food sector is responsible for one-third of greenhouse gas emissions, with animal agriculture accounting for 60% of that total. Animal agriculture is the primary threat to biodiversity. Agriculture occupies 50% of the world’s habitable land, with 83% of this land used for animal agriculture yet the latter produces only 18% of the calories consumed. Farming accounts for 70% of freshwater withdrawals. Animal agriculture is a big user of freshwater. For example, dairy milk requires 628 litres of water to produce one litre of milk, and soy plant-based milk requires only 27 litres of water to produce the same amount.

Fight factory farming with diet change not climate change, which animal welfare approaches make worse!

A 2026 UK egg industry study found that converting the UK’s egg supply to organic free-range would nearly double greenhouse gas emissions compared to a fully caged system. Cage-free systems would require 1.68 million more hens to match the same quantity of eggs produced from battery cage systems. As the chart above illustrates, animal welfare improvements within animal agriculture exacerbate environmental harms. Cage-free egg systems increase greenhouse gas emissions, eutrophication, acidification, and land use relative to caged systems. Plant-based foods, on the other hand, offer a pathway that avoids this select-welfare–environment trade-off and performs better across all environmental indicators.

A major problem of corporate campaigns advocating for cage-free eggs is investments in “stranded assets.” Cage-free commitments can lock in long-term infrastructure investments in egg production due to the costs for new housing, equipment, and farm retrofits. In Europe, completing the shift away from cages is estimated to require €2–3.2 billion in additional investment, with producers expecting these facilities to operate for 10–15 years or more to recoup costs. Such long-lived infrastructure inadvertently strengthens economic and political incentives to sustain egg production throughout the asset’s lifespan, making our future transition to plant-based systems slower and more expensive. Investing in cage-free factory farms leaves us with stranded assets due to the worsening climate crisis and land and water overuse. Continued investment in cage-free infrastructure risks locking philanthropy into stranded assets designed to perpetuate animal agriculture for decades. 

Signals that the current food system is unsustainable and faltering are already appearing. Animal farming is a leading contributor to the climate crisis, which in turn creates climate impacts which affect farmed animals. Chickens are very susceptible to extreme heat and suffer enormously because they are unable to sweat to cool down and become dehydrated as they pant. The heatwave that gripped Western Europe in June 2026 killed 2.5 to 3 million chickens and turkeys in France, overwhelming carcass collection services in Brittany and Pays de la Loire, the country’s two largest chicken farm regions.

  • Chickens dying of heat stroke during heat waves: In June 2021, a heat dome caused an unprecedented heat wave in British Columbia in which at least 651,000 chickens and turkeys died.
  • Sea creatures overheating in heat waves: during this same “heat dome” event of June 24-30, 2021, 1 billion sea creatures were slowly cooked and killed in the warming oceans off the coast of western Canada. These included intertidal animals—such as mussels, clams, sea stars, and barnacles. 
  • Wild animals killed and displaced in wildfires: 3 billion wild animals were killed or displaced by the Australian mega wildfires in 2019-2020. The wildlife toll included 143 million mammals, 2.46 billion reptiles, 180 million birds, and 51 million frogs.
  • Threat of climate change to quintillions (1018) of insects: Climate change directly threatens and harms the lives of quintillions of insects due to severe weather events, droughts, and changes to ecosystem niches. According to an article in Science, “with current pledges, corresponding to ~3.2°C warming, climatically determined geographic range losses of >50% are projected in ~49% of insects, 44% of plants, and 26% of vertebrates.”
  • Mangrove forest cover is being removed in Indonesia to expand shrimp farms, reports BBC’s Climate Question’s special segment “Where have all the mangroves gone?” Instead of funding shrimp welfare campaigns the emphasis should be on preventing new shrimp farms from forming by promoting plant-based alternatives.

Estimated numbers of individual animals directly harmed by animal agriculture, fishing, and aquaculture, alongside wild animals belonging to species such as wild mammals, wild birds, insects, and aquatic animals, including freshwater species and marine species, threatened with extinction due to climate change (original graphic for the Beyond Cage-Free report).

Health

Diets centred on whole plant foods which prioritize healthy, fiber and nutrient-rich foods reduce risks of cardiovascular disease and other chronic illnesses while lowering dietary cholesterol. Reducing dependence on intensive animal agriculture also helps lower antimicrobial resistance and future zoonotic disease risks.

Limiting egg consumption to reduce cardiovascular and all-cause mortality risk: In large US cohorts, each additional half egg per day was associated with a 6% higher risk of incident cardiovascular disease and an 8% higher risk of all-cause mortality and a 7% higher mortality risk—associations largely driven by dietary cholesterol. Dose-response meta-analyses reinforce a graded risk, with each additional egg or 50-g increment per day associated with roughly a 6% higher all-cause mortality and an 8% higher cardiovascular risk in US cohorts. Substituting plant protein for egg protein was associated with about 19% lower all-cause mortality, indicating eggs compare unfavorably to plant-based sources, and higher intake carries particular risk in vulnerable groups (42% higher type 2 diabetes risk comparing highest to lowest intake, and 69% higher cardiovascular risk among people with diabetes). Given minimal nutritional downside to moderation, reducing egg and dietary cholesterol intake, and favoring plant-based protein is a prudent component of a heart-healthy diet.

Pandemic risk: According to the US Center for Disease Control and Prevention, 75% of emerging infectious diseases in humans originate from the farming of animals for food, clothing, and other purposes. Zoonotic diseases, which are diseases that transfer from nonhuman animals to human animals, have been responsible for a significant number of epidemics and pandemics in recent years. Notable examples include HIV, avian flu, swine flu, SARS, Ebola, and most prominently, COVID-19.

Food security: As our planet heats up, plants and animals are pushed outside their climate niches. Conditions become too hot and dry for human societies and ecosystems to thrive, and these impacts are associated with lower food production. Every fraction of a degree of global warming will worsen the situation due to food and water shortages and other crises. By 2030, crop yield failures could be 4.5 times higher. By 2050, the likelihood shoots up to 25 times current rates, and the world could be facing a rice or wheat failure every other year, with the probability of soybean and maize failures even higher. By 2050, synchronized failure across all four crops becomes a possibility every 11 years. 

Animal agriculture, an extremely inefficient system to feed the global human population, jeopardises food security and the UN Sustainable Development Goal number two to end world hunger. George Monbiot notes that “while human population growth rates have fallen to 1.05 per cent, the population of farmed animals is growing by 2.4 per cent per year. The biggest population crisis is the growth of the number of farmed animals, not human animals. “By 2050, to put it in brutal terms, the extra humans on the planet will weigh a little over 100 million tons, whereas, unless the current trend is disrupted, the extra farm[ed] animals will weigh 400 million tons.”

We must mitigate climate change, and we need to adapt by diversifying crop production and prioritizing crops for human consumption, rather than growing crops to feed farmed animals. A shift toward plant-based food systems can improve food security and help mitigate climate change.

Choice

These animal, climate, ecological, and health benefits should not be considered negative externalities but added up in a holistic approach. In his book The Most Good You Can Do, Peter Singer writes: “eliminating or decreasing the consumption of animal products will benefit animals, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and lessen the chances of a pandemic resulting from a virus evolving among the animals crowded into today’s factory farms, which are an ideal breeding ground for viruses. That therefore looks like a high-priority strategy.” 

A plant-based food strategy outperforms an animal welfare approach by eliminating and reducing the consumption of animal products, mitigating climate change, mass extinction, land and freshwater use, improving public health outcomes, enhancing food security, and increasing access to affordable and healthy foods. The optimal food system and optimal diet are plant-based. For example, shifting food systems could cut agricultural land use by up to 75%, from 4 billion to 1 billion hectares. 

At this critical juncture, a ‘third wave of American philanthropy,’ driven by AI wealth is flowing into farmed animal welfare funders, such as Coefficient Giving, the Centre for Effective Altruism (CEA), Navigation Fund, and Animal Charity Evaluators. The majority of the AI windfall is currently directed to animal welfare within factory farms, with the CEA, for example, requesting proposals for ‘a cage-free future for laying hens’ while explicitly excluding institutional meat reduction, alternative protein work, and individual vegan outreach. Coefficient Giving listed priorities such as improving killing methods for fish, shrimp, and insects. On the other hand, there is movement toward demand reduction for animal products, with Coefficient Giving funding plant-based alternative proteins as a priority initiative as well.

Animal philanthropy needs to completely pivot to a holistic high-priority strategy of eliminating or reducing the consumption of animal products by promoting plant-based food systems.

An increased supply of plant-based foods and diet change offers a more direct, faster path to peaking and then reducing the rapidly growing numbers of animals bred in a cruel system. This win-win approach provides multiple benefits for climate action and public health while reducing the exploitation and suffering of farmed animals and wildlife alike.

It is a moral and strategic mistake for AI companies to invest in factory farming rather than plant-based foods at a time when they are facing growing criticism over the environmental impacts of data centers. Rather, the priority should be to lead the shift towards plant-based food systems and help offset the impacts of data centers. In a May 2026 Gallup poll, 71% of Americans oppose local data centers. According to Data Center Watch, “At least 75 data center projects worth approximately $130 billion were blocked or delayed in a single quarter [first quarter of 2026] — roughly matching the scale of all of 2025 in just three months” and “the number of active opposition groups more than doubled across 49 states.”

Investing philanthropy funds from AI’s in cage-free campaigns would exacerbate the environmental costs and some additional animal welfare risks, according to PETA’s White Paper. Recognizing animal suffering, the climate change, and public health problems as interlinked cascading crises with a common solution – i.e., plant-based food system change – accelerates progress in all areas, including moving as quickly as possible towards net zero.

Outcome

We are calling on AI and animal philanthropists to pivot their funding away from welfarist reforms and toward systemic plant-based initiatives that will ultimately end factory farming rather than redesign it. This is not a call for philanthropists to abandon animal welfare funding, but to redirect it. A holistic, systems approach to animal welfare, climate and health suggests that funders direct resources towards increasing the supply and demand of plant-based food. Shifting support toward plant-based food systems would reduce the number of animals in the food system, and accelerate progress in other areas through multiplier plant-based interventions. Plant-based food system interventions would save billions of animals from suffering and exploitation, mitigate climate change, reduce freshwater and land use, reduce zoonotic disease threat, improve public health, and enhance food security. New effective tools are emerging to promote plant-based eating, backed by a growing plant-based grassroots and advocacy movement eager to scale them.

Recommendations

01

Broaden the Effective Altruism philosophy beyond utilitarianism and adopt a new impact metric focused on reducing the total number of animals bred into the food system.

We need to go beyond Peter Singer’s utilitarian approach, which has had a limiting impact on campaigns giving preference to concerns about animal suffering and welfare reforms. What is needed are a deontological philosophy and a holistic, ecological systems approach. Deontology is a philosophy of duty and rights: in this context, an animal is not merely property and a commodity but an individual or a subject-of-a-life with rights and personhood. In a holistic approach, the key metric is the number of farmed animals used in the food system. At present, cage-free campaigns are based on the number of animals spared from cages, a method which does not encourage a reduction in the total number of animals that are bred and leads to an increase in environmental impacts.

02

Develop an “Action Plan for a Plant-Based Future” that addresses both supply and demand

Developing a plan that includes a shift in farm subsidies towards fruits, vegetables, grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds; public information campaigns; city and national action plans for plant-based food; alternative protein innovations; plant-based procurement at institutions such as councils, universities, schools, and hospitals; plant-based days like Meat Free Mondays; science-based country food guidelines; and plant-based by default. Plant-based meal replacements are cost-effective, like New York City defaulting to plant-based meals in public hospitals saving over $500,000 a year. 

03

Develop a High Ambition Coalition for Plant-Based Food Systems Transformation.

Convene funders, animal protection organizations, plant-based food system advocates, climate scientists, public health experts, and food justice organizations for open dialogue on how philanthropic funding for plant-based food system change can generate benefits across multiple societal challenges.

Conclusion

An unsustainable food system is one of the greatest systemic risks facing life on Earth, accelerating climate change, biodiversity loss, pandemic risk, and chronic disease while driving the exploitation and suffering of billions of animals each year. The AI windfall presents a historic opportunity to invest in interventions that do the greatest overall good across multiple global challenges. Plant-based food system transformation is not simply an animal welfare intervention—it is a multiplier intervention that simultaneously advances animal protection, climate mitigation, biodiversity conservation, public health, and food security.

Please add your name and organization as a signatory to this letter and its recommendations.

View our Expert Signatories

Loading



View our Group Signatories

Loading



Open Letter translations

We need your voice.
Add your name to our Open Letter:

Your information is collected and processed in accordance with applicable data protection and privacy laws.
See our Privacy Policy for details.

This letter is supported by…

Expert Signatories

Group Signatories

Individual Signatories

Bigger cages aren’t the solution. Plant-based food systems are.

Instead of expanding meat, dairy, and egg consumption, a group of 200 climate scientists points to the urgent need for food system change by 2030 to meet the Paris climate targets and avoid 2 degrees Celsius of catastrophic warming.

– Helen Harwatt et al. (2024)

Instead of expanding meat, dairy, and egg consumption, a group of 200 climate scientists points to the urgent need for food system change by 2030 to meet the Paris climate targets and avoid 2 degrees Celsius of catastrophic warming.

– Helen Harwatt et al. (2024)